Classic Potato Salad Recipe

There’s something unmistakably comforting about a bowl of classic potato salad. It’s the kind of dish that quietly steals the show at backyard barbecues, family gatherings, and potlucks.

This recipe was born from a desire to go back to basics—to create a potato salad that was nostalgic yet fresh, creamy yet bright, simple yet deeply satisfying.

Everyone seems to have a memory attached to potato salad. Maybe it’s your grandma’s big mixing bowl of it in the summer, or the creamy store-bought version someone always brought to picnics.

Whatever the story, the perfect potato salad is worth mastering. And this version is exactly that—familiar and timeless, with just enough nuance to make it special.

Why I Love This Recipe

This potato salad hits the perfect balance between creamy and tangy.

What makes it truly special is the texture: fork-tender potatoes that don’t fall apart, a velvety dressing that clings without being heavy, and a mix-in combination that brings both crunch and flavor to the table.

It’s the kind of recipe you can make ahead, tweak to your taste, and serve all year long—but it really shines in warmer months when picnic tables beg for something chilled and substantial.

The dressing is where the magic happens—made with mayonnaise, a touch of Dijon mustard, apple cider vinegar for bite, and a hint of sweetness from relish.

Then you get classic add-ins: finely chopped celery for crunch, red onion for bite, and hard-boiled eggs for richness. You can always throw in extras like chopped dill pickles or fresh herbs if you’re feeling fancy.

Whether you’re preparing for a Fourth of July cookout or just looking to round out a grilled dinner, this potato salad is a guaranteed crowd-pleaser. It holds up beautifully in the fridge and gets even better with time, which makes it one of my go-to make-ahead sides.

Ingredients for Classic Potato Salad

To make a really good classic potato salad, you’ll need ingredients that focus on freshness and balance. Nothing fussy—just real ingredients prepared with care.

Potatoes
Choose waxy varieties like Yukon Gold or red potatoes. They hold their shape after boiling and have a creamy texture without getting mealy.

Mayonnaise
This forms the base of the dressing. Go for full-fat for the richest taste, or a good-quality avocado mayo for a slightly healthier spin.

Dijon Mustard
Adds a gentle tang and depth without overpowering the salad.

Apple Cider Vinegar
Brightens the flavors and helps the potatoes absorb seasoning while they’re warm.

Celery
Provides crunch and freshness.

Red Onion or Shallots
For a touch of sharpness and color.

Sweet Pickle Relish
Brings a sweet-sour balance that keeps the dressing interesting.

Hard-Boiled Eggs
Creamy, protein-rich, and essential in traditional recipes.

Salt and Pepper
Don’t skip seasoning—the potatoes need a generous amount of salt, especially during boiling.

Fresh Herbs (optional)
Dill and chives are especially lovely if you want to add a fresh garden note.

How Much Time Will You Need?

This recipe is a breeze to pull together once you understand the flow.

Here’s the time breakdown:

• Prep time: 20 minutes
• Cook time: 20 minutes
• Chill time: 1 hour (optional but recommended)

Total time: Around 40 minutes hands-on, but give it an extra hour in the fridge if you want those flavors to deepen and meld.

How to Make This Classic Potato Salad

Here’s a complete, detailed walkthrough to help you nail the texture, flavor, and balance every single time.

Step 1: Boil the Potatoes

Scrub 2½ pounds of Yukon Gold or red potatoes, then cut them into bite-sized chunks. You can peel them if you prefer, but keeping the skins adds color and texture.

Place them in a large pot and cover with cold water. Add a generous pinch of salt—this is your chance to season from within.

Bring to a boil, then reduce to a simmer. Cook for 10–15 minutes or until just fork-tender. Don’t overcook, or they’ll fall apart later.

Step 2: Drain and Cool

Once the potatoes are tender, drain them in a colander. Immediately spread them out on a baking sheet or large tray so they cool evenly and don’t steam each other.

While they’re still warm, sprinkle 1 tablespoon of apple cider vinegar over them. This helps flavor the potatoes right away.

Let them cool to room temperature.

Step 3: Prepare the Dressing

In a large mixing bowl, whisk together:

• 1 cup mayonnaise
• 2 teaspoons Dijon mustard
• 1 tablespoon sweet pickle relish
• Salt and black pepper to taste

If you like your salad a little looser or tangier, add 1–2 tablespoons of pickle juice or more vinegar.

Step 4: Add Mix-ins

Dice 2 celery stalks and ¼ cup of red onion or shallots.

Chop 3 hard-boiled eggs into bite-sized pieces.

Add these to the bowl with the dressing and fold gently.

Step 5: Combine with Potatoes

Once the potatoes have cooled completely, add them to the bowl in batches.

Use a spatula or large spoon to gently fold the dressing into the potatoes. Be careful not to mash them—you want defined chunks with creamy coating.

Taste and adjust the seasoning as needed—add more salt, pepper, or vinegar depending on your preference.

Step 6: Chill and Serve

Transfer to a serving bowl, cover, and refrigerate for at least 1 hour before serving.

Before serving, sprinkle with fresh dill or chopped chives if desired. You can also top with extra sliced eggs or paprika for visual appeal.

Substitutions

One of the reasons potato salad is so beloved is its flexibility. Here are some smart swaps:

• Mayonnaise: Swap with Greek yogurt or sour cream for a tangier and lighter dressing.
• Mustard: Try whole grain mustard for texture or honey mustard for sweetness.
• Relish: Use finely chopped dill pickles or gherkins if you prefer less sweetness.
• Onion: Substitute red onion with green onions or shallots for a milder flavor.
• Eggs: Skip them if you’re serving vegan or egg-free guests.
• Potatoes: While Yukon Gold and red potatoes are ideal, russets can be used—just handle them gently as they’re starchier.

These small swaps can accommodate dietary needs or personal preferences without compromising flavor.

Best Side Dishes for Classic Potato Salad

This salad is hearty enough to stand alone but really shines next to smoky, savory mains. Here are three of my favorite pairings:

1. Grilled BBQ Chicken
Juicy, sticky-sweet, and smoky—this makes a dream combo with the creamy tang of potato salad.

2. Corn on the Cob with Herb Butter
Serve warm, slathered with garlic-parsley butter. It’s simple, seasonal, and always a hit.

3. Baked Beans
Sweet, savory baked beans offer a rich contrast and round out a classic cookout plate.

Serving and Presentation Tips

Potato salad may be humble, but a thoughtful presentation turns it into a showpiece.

Use a shallow serving dish rather than a deep bowl so guests can easily scoop portions without mashing the potatoes. A white ceramic platter or vintage glass bowl creates a homey, timeless look.

Garnish is key—a light dusting of smoked paprika, a few sprigs of fresh dill or parsley, or sliced hard-boiled eggs arranged on top all elevate the appearance without extra effort.

Right before serving, give it a gentle stir to refresh the dressing and make it look creamy again—potato salad tends to stiffen as it chills.

If serving outdoors, place the bowl on top of a larger bowl filled with ice to keep it cool and food-safe for longer. Use a slotted spoon for serving, so people don’t end up with too much dressing in one scoop.

Tips and Tricks to Make This Recipe Even Better

Want your potato salad to go from “good” to “absolutely perfect”? These expert tips will help.

• Season your potato water. Add salt to the boiling water generously—think seawater levels. This is your first and best chance to flavor the potatoes from within.
• Toss the potatoes with vinegar while warm. This trick locks in tang and ensures flavor gets into each bite, not just the dressing on top.
• Use a mix of potato sizes. Cutting your potatoes in slightly irregular shapes (some small, some chunkier) adds visual interest and improves texture.
• Chill the salad, but stir just before serving. It needs at least an hour to let flavors meld, but give it a gentle mix before serving to restore creaminess.
• Customize with crunch. Add extras like diced pickles, capers, or even crispy bacon if you want layers of texture.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Even classic recipes can go sideways without a few key precautions. Avoid these pitfalls:

• Overcooking the potatoes. Mushy potatoes will fall apart during mixing. You want them just tender when pierced with a fork.
• Not cooling the potatoes before mixing. Warm potatoes can turn the mayonnaise greasy and lead to a separated dressing.
• Under-seasoning. Potatoes are bland on their own—salt them at every stage (boiling water, dressing, final mix).
• Skipping the chill. While it’s tempting to serve immediately, the salad improves dramatically after resting in the fridge.
• Adding raw onion too early. Letting onions sit in the dressing too long can make it overly sharp. If prepping ahead, add onions just before serving or soak them briefly in vinegar first.

How to Store It

Proper storage helps maintain flavor and texture for days.

• Refrigerate in an airtight container. This prevents it from absorbing fridge odors and keeps it creamy.
• Chill for at least 1 hour before serving to allow the flavors to meld.
• Keeps well for 3–4 days in the fridge. In fact, it’s often better the next day.
• Don’t freeze it. Mayo-based salads don’t freeze well—freezing ruins the texture.
• If the dressing thickens too much after refrigeration, stir in a tablespoon of milk or more mayo before serving to loosen it up.

FAQ

Q1: Can I make potato salad the day before?
Yes! In fact, it tastes even better the next day once the flavors have had time to develop.

Q2: What kind of potatoes are best for this salad?
Waxy varieties like Yukon Gold or red potatoes hold their shape and stay creamy. Avoid russets unless you like a softer texture.

Q3: Is this potato salad gluten-free?
Yes—as long as all your condiments (like mustard and relish) are gluten-free. Always check the labels.

Q4: Can I leave out the eggs?
Absolutely. While eggs add richness and protein, the salad is still delicious without them.

Q5: How long can I leave potato salad out at room temperature?
Two hours is the max. If it’s a hot day, reduce that to one hour, or serve over ice to keep it safe.

Print